This cake is excerpted from American Cake, a beautiful new book by Nashvillian Anne Byrn, (aka The Cake Mix Doctor).
Placing food in pie pastry is a centuries-old tradition that allows you to eat with your hands and take food with you. The Pennsylvania Dutch placed molasses crumb cake in a piecrust and called it Shoofly Pie in the 1880s. With the spongy texture of cake and the crust of pie, this dessert is the most beloved of the Southeastern Pennsylvania region where it was born. According to historian William Woys Weaver, Shoofly Pie began as Centennial Cake in 1876, baked in a pan without a crust. The crust was later added so people could eat the cake with their hands over their morning coffee. Weaver says the name “Shoofly” comes from Shoofly the Boxing Mule, a popular circus animal at the time, and the Shoofly name was branded onto foods like Shoofly molasses, a key ingredient in this dessert. The combination of molasses, coffee, and spices in the batter bakes into an almost chocolate-like taste, and this pie/cake is incredibly delicious warm with coffee or tea. This recipe is adapted slightly from Weaver’s book As American as Shoofly Pie: The Foodlore and Fakelore of Pennsylvania Dutch Cuisine.